Don Matheson and Roger Berry (current national champion 3 & 4 wall) also fell victim to Jay's skills. Jay had an ability to lull an opponent into thinking "this guy is no sweat he hits it so easy" type of first game strategy. But Jay's game tactics almost always included a mandatory 3rd game as he really was a momentum player building steam later in the match. Not always in the best shape on the court he was known to get "beet red" in his tenacity to chase the ball down despite being winded. If a third game was required he also used tremendous amounts of off speed shots and side wall dying kills in the corner. He knew how to bait the power players, and never seemed to expel himself more then what was required to win. It was not unusual to see him win many a close game but it was never in doubt about the outcome. Jay always enjoyed a good match at the regional and national level as well never shying away from competition. At the NYAC in NYC he especially did well in the Open Doubles division. He played against pros of the time Ken Ginty, Fred Lewis and Joel Wisotsky. Against such tough matches he was inevitably a winner or runner up. Some of these players are now even in the USA National HOF.
Also he played against Virginia HOF nominee Claude Benham losing in 3 games 21-16, 10-21 and 21-16. The Cherry Blossom Festival of Metro DC saw him also barely lose to HOFer Irishman Pat Kirby in the 1979 tourney there. His game was well known by most along the east coast In a particular memorable game against Mike Griffin he won the battle of the city championship 10 years ago in 1992 his last singles entered in a near 3 hour battle captured on video. Also mentioned in the Griffin bio was his memorable win against the national 50 and over number one seed from California in 1993. Jay was a very confident player and used timeouts and other psychological strategies to his benefit. He won perhaps over 40 city, state and regional tournaments and is considered by many as the second best player to come for the Old Dominion. Although retired from our great game he always finds time to ski and enjoy an occasional party!